Journalist Will Puckett admits he might never attend another execution after witnessing the case of Christa Pike, though he stands by his decision to be present.
Puckett, who serves as the morning co-anchor for WVLT-TV in Knoxville, Tennessee, was among seven reporters chosen to observe the execution of Christa Pike, who, despite receiving two doses of pentobarbital on Wednesday, remains alive and in critical condition.
“When you agree to be a state-appointed witness to such an event, you understand the potential for it to be traumatic,” Puckett stated during an interview with As It Happens host Nil Köksal.
“And that’s precisely what we’re discussing today, which is conveying how the state of Tennessee failed to execute Christa Gail Pike correctly and effectively.”
At 50 years old, Pike was just 18 in January 1995 when she, along with her boyfriend Tadaryl Shipp and another individual, lured their classmate, 19-year-old Colleen Slemmer, into a wooded area where they brutally tortured and murdered her.
Both Pike and Shipp admitted to the crime and were convicted of first-degree murder. Pike received a death sentence, while Shipp, who was 17 at the time, was sentenced to life imprisonment. Over the years, Pike has expressed regret for her actions.
Her legal team and advocates attempted to obtain a stay of execution, arguing her young age at the time of the offense, mental health challenges, and a background of severe childhood neglect and abuse.
May Martinez, Slemmer’s mother, publicly supported the execution, stating that she has long awaited the implementation of Pike’s sentence.
‘She should not be talking’
As Puckett and the other witnesses entered the execution chamber on Wednesday and took their seats at 6:41 p.m., the window behind which Pike lay strapped to a gurney was obscured by curtains and blinds.
He noted that witnesses are not permitted to see the procedure of the needle being placed into the inmate’s arm.
This was Puckett’s first experience attending an execution, and he was told by more experienced reporters that the entire process typically lasts about 30 minutes.
However, by the time 30 minutes elapsed, the curtains still had not been drawn back.
“One of Christa Gail Pike’s pre-execution concerns was her small veins,” Puckett remarked. “If you consider her complaint alongside her medical history, it’s reasonable to conclude they were struggling to locate a suitable vein for the injection.”
When the curtains finally opened at 7:26, Pike appeared almost “jovial,” according to Puckett. She made her final statements.
“She simply stated, ‘I’m going to leave this world the way I’ve lived most of my life, in love,'” he reported.
“She also mentioned, ‘I’m going to love those who hate me the most because they are the ones who need love the most,’ concluding with, ‘I’m good now. I’m at peace. I’m ready to be free; I’m going to celebrate my freedom. This is a good day.’
Notably, she did not reference Colleen Slemmer or her crime, Puckett remarked.

May Martinez, right, mother of murder victim Colleen Slemmer, leaves Riverbend Maximum Security Institution during a stay of Pike’s scheduled execution. (George Walker IV/The Associated Press)
Pike reported feeling physical discomfort, according to Puckett.
“She said, ‘The vein in my arm feels like it’s about to burst.’ That was at 7:33. A minute later, she remarked, ‘One spot is really throbbing,'” he noted.
“At that moment, my colleagues, who had witnessed executions previously, looked at me and commented, ‘This is not normal. She should not be talking. Clearly, she should be in the process of dying.’ Yet she wasn’t.”
‘Why are we not viewing this?’
Puckett observed that Pike took several deep breaths before gasping. At 7:46 p.m., officials once again closed the curtains for three minutes.
When the curtains reopened, Pike was snoring. Shortly after 8:05 p.m., the curtains were drawn once more.
“There were numerous people asking: ‘This clearly isn’t going as planned. What can you tell us? Why can’t we see this?'” Puckett recounted.
The media representatives did not receive any answers, and Pike’s snoring could still be heard behind the curtain until the microphone was silenced around 8:53 p.m.
Following that, the witnesses were escorted out.

A photo from December 4, 2007, shows Pike arriving at Knox County Criminal Court in Knoxville. (USA Today Network/Reuters)
Randall Spivey, one of Pike’s attorneys, informed reporters on Thursday afternoon that his client is currently in a Nashville hospital receiving “life-saving medical care.”
“Christa is alive at this moment,” he stated. “We do not yet have information regarding her prognosis or any updates on her health.”
Governor Bill Lee of Tennessee has called for a suspension of all scheduled executions in the state for the remainder of the year, along with a third-party investigation into the failed execution attempt on Wednesday.
-
What happened in Tennessee’s failed execution of Christa Pike and what comes next?
-
Tennessee governor orders outside review after death row inmate Christa Pike survives execution attempt
When asked about his feelings following the events of Wednesday, Puckett shifted the focus away from himself.
“Our role is not to be the focus; I’ve made an effort to put myself into, for lack of a better term, robot mode,” he remarked. “I’m alright at this moment.”
In a case as prominent and contentious as Pike’s, Puckett emphasizes the importance of his role as “an impartial witness” to the events that transpired on Wednesday night.
“It certainly has me contemplating whether I will undertake such a task again,” he admitted. “However, it was crucial for me to be there to ensure the state executed this properly and to represent the eyes and ears of the public who are unable to witness what occurs in that room.”
Tag: rewrite-pending


